We all know insurance companies are evil, right? They try not to pay claims, they automatically deny claims, they rake in huge profits for the owners and they would rather that people just die than make a claim. That's what many, many people believe, and who can blame them? We are presented with that image in movies and on television, in popular fiction and in the media. Lots of people probably remember as I do, a novel turned movie starring Matt Damon, wherein a health insurance company just does anything and everything within their power to avoid paying for a subscriber's leukemia treatments. I have heard the expression "It works like an insurance company" used to describe some business or institution that doesn't seem to want to pay out when they should.

So, what is the reality? That largely depends on your frame of reference-evil is subjective after all-so how do we define the moral character of an insurance company? I think we should avoid the question of morals at all. Instead we should focus on the word 'ethical'. 

Are insurers ethical then? Well, some more than others. The large companies you can count on to act ethically, or to at least fix it when they don't. Any unethical behavior you see in an insurance company will be an oversight (which doesn't make it better) rather than a matter of policy. Why? Easy. Insurance companies are self interested. You can count on them to look out for who they are beholden to, the shareholders. All companies are self interested in some way. Even non profits have to have enough self interest to turn a profit and keep the lights on at least, right?

The single most damaging thing an insurance company could possibly do to itself would be to gain a reputation for non payment. Think about it. Would you gamble at a casino in Las Vegas if you knew that slot machine would never pay? Or when you went to the cage to turn in your chips, they told you to get lost? Of course you wouldn't. Neither would anyone else. Not to mention there are extremely stringent state laws that are designed to prevent insurance companies from doing that, laws that carry penalties so stiff that even a single infraction could cause a company to lose the privilege of doing business at all in the state in which the infraction was committed. Can you imagine what it would do to the company's bottom line if they lost the ability to do their Medicare business in say, Florida? It would be devastating. Catastrophically so. Insurance companies take this very seriously. When the condition that triggers the payout has been met, they WILL pay. 

Here is the catch: The conditions that trigger a payout are exact. They mean what they say and they set a line in the sand. That line moves for no one.

An example: You have a policy that states that injuries sustained while skydiving won't be paid for. You go skydiving and break your leg. While getting into your chute, still on the ground. Fall right over and crack a femur on the pavement stepping into the harness. They aren't going to pay. You didn't jump out of a plane, but the policy says no injuries sustained while engaged in the activities of or relating to skydiving. Putting on the chute is one of those activities. So they aren't going to pay-even though you didn't even board the aircraft, let alone get off of the ground.

This is where customers of insurance companies start waiving their arms in the air and stomping the ground (carefully, they have broken femurs) screaming "no fair". 

Did the company act ethically? You bet. That exclusion (skydiving and skydiving related activities) is spelled out clearly in the policy. Were they acting self interestedly? Yes, absolutely. Not paying claims for dangerous behavior saves the company money, which ultimately puts money in shareholder's pockets. Here is some good news: You may be a shareholder. Many insurance companies are member owned. A small silver lining. When your insurance company sends you a check paying you back some amount of your premiums, that is why. it is your dividends coming in.

If you take nothing else from this article, let it be this: Your insurance company will pay for anything they say they will in your policy. Also, they will pay for precisely nothing that they don't say they will. Read your policies carefully friends. Take the knowledge you gain from doing so and run it by a licensed agent. A licensed agent exists, literally, to help you make heads or tails of that policy you have in front of you. Hopefully before you sign it.

                                           Written by Joseph Smith, licensed agent